At the all-boys school I attended from around the age of 11 onwards, corporal punishment wasn't heavily used but it was not unusual either. There were two styles. Firstly, there were fairly informal punishments doled out in the classroom. Most times these involved a slipper (gymshoe, plimsoll, whatever) although rulers and other implements were also used, but not ones that would be specifically designed or made for giving punishments. These punishments weren't usually especially severe - my impression was that they were mostly used to calm things down a bit by making an example of one miscreant. I'm 99% sure these were never recorded in any sort of punishment book or student file. I'm pretty confident that most of the class, excepting the one on the receiving end, positively enjoyed the spectacle - I certainly did!
Then there were other occasions, rather more rare, when someone did something more seriously wrong and they would be sent to the deputy headmaster's office and he would cane them across the seat of their trousers. It was apparent to everyone that these were no laughing matter and left formidable marks that would last a week or more. I would guess that about nine times out of ten such cases just involved a single pupil and it must have been quite scary being made to stand in the office with this intimidating senior member of staff telling you off and knowing what was likely to follow. However, on just a few occasions there was more than one pupil involved - in one instance for example, three boys from my class were sent to him for bullying a younger pupil.
That scenario fascinates me but as I never had to make such a visit the the deputy head, either alone or with others, I can only speculate on the different emotional experiences. I imagine, but I could be wrong, that the telling-off part would have been slightly easier to cope with if you weren't on your own. But after that... Take the 'three boy' scenario I mentioned before. Suppose, because of where you were standing, you were going to be the last to be caned. Do you think you could get any enjoyment from seeing the first one being caned or the second? Or would the thought that this was a about to happen to you be too scary to entertain any pleasure feelings? Conversely, suppose you happened to be first - once you'd had your caning, it would obviously still be hurting quite a lot but knowing that the worst is over, would you be able to get any enjoyment from watching your colleagues getting theirs??
Then there were other occasions, rather more rare, when someone did something more seriously wrong and they would be sent to the deputy headmaster's office and he would cane them across the seat of their trousers. It was apparent to everyone that these were no laughing matter and left formidable marks that would last a week or more. I would guess that about nine times out of ten such cases just involved a single pupil and it must have been quite scary being made to stand in the office with this intimidating senior member of staff telling you off and knowing what was likely to follow. However, on just a few occasions there was more than one pupil involved - in one instance for example, three boys from my class were sent to him for bullying a younger pupil.
That scenario fascinates me but as I never had to make such a visit the the deputy head, either alone or with others, I can only speculate on the different emotional experiences. I imagine, but I could be wrong, that the telling-off part would have been slightly easier to cope with if you weren't on your own. But after that... Take the 'three boy' scenario I mentioned before. Suppose, because of where you were standing, you were going to be the last to be caned. Do you think you could get any enjoyment from seeing the first one being caned or the second? Or would the thought that this was a about to happen to you be too scary to entertain any pleasure feelings? Conversely, suppose you happened to be first - once you'd had your caning, it would obviously still be hurting quite a lot but knowing that the worst is over, would you be able to get any enjoyment from watching your colleagues getting theirs??

