The future of spanking (2)

A few reactions to my previous comment on the future of spankings -some direct and some here. I guess part of my thinking is that undoubtedly I was affected by being at school in an era when corporal punishment still happened but what works for me in videos, photo-fantasies etc. is already very much towards the modern end of things. I don't get much reaction usually to historical pieces, maids outfits, and even (shock, horror!) to stockings and suspenders. I emphasise usually because it can sometimes work for me - for example a story with a modern girl dressing in stockings and suspenders while "on the pull" being brought to book by an angry father/boyfriend/husband. I do like adults role-playing schoolgirl scenarios but the more contemporary the dress the better and ideally I like it where either the author has imagined a time in the near future when corporal punishment has been re-established in schools and the home, or perhaps where a girl accepts an unofficial punishment rather than face the consequences of the properly prescribed outcome. Also, while on the odd occasion I've stumbled across something on the web that appears non-consensual, it's just sickened me, I don't much want to see the girl laughing it off - you know, corporal punishment. The clue's in the name! It's supposed to be a punishment, and even in a role play, the subject should be nervous, ashamed or at least - by the end of it - reduced to a few tears.